5 Young NFL Stars Who Are Locks for the Hall of Fame — And 5 Who Will Bust
This article was originally published on Total Pro Sports.
Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, and Justin Jefferson are just a handful of young NFL stars who showed that you oughta believe the hype when they produce early.
Then again, former so-called “future stars” like Robert Griffin and Sam Bradford serve as cautionary tales that a hot start doesn’t mean long-term success in the pros.
With that, let’s dive into five young NFL stars who will become Hall of Famers, and five hype machines that will fizzle out soon.
Which young NFL stars will be Hall of Famers and which ones will not?
Become A Hall Of Famer: Drake Maye
We know that the loss to the Seattle Seahawks in Super Bowl 60 was tough for New England Patriots fans to watch. Now, try imagining how painful it was for Maye.
Maye stood no chance behind that vaunted Seattle defense, taking six sacks and turning the ball over three times. But you wanna know something funny? John Elway lost his first three Super Bowls before winning two of his own.
The Patriots had zero expectations in 2025. Maye finished second in MVP voting behind Matthew Stafford after throwing for 4,394 yards and 31 touchdowns against only eight interceptions. His Pats were one win away from a seventh Lombardi Trophy.
Don’t you think for a minute that this was peak Drake Maye? Folks, it was only the beginning.
Maye and Mike Vrabel are just starting their operation together. And the Patriots’ offensive line can only get better after being ripped apart in the postseason. And yeah, the weaponry around Maye will get better. Stefon Diggs isn’t gonna be his only Pro Bowl-caliber receiver.
It’s more than talent and stats. It’s poise, calmness, and swagger. Maye showed he had it all in year one. We would not be shocked if he won multiple Super Bowls and MVP awards. So, Canton members, feel free to get an early head start on that Hall of Fame bust.
Fizzle Out: Jayden Daniels
Daniels had arguably the greatest rookie quarterback season ever in 2024.
The former No. 2 pick and 2023 Heisman Trophy winner completed 69 percent of pass attempts for 3,568 yards, 25 touchdowns, and only nine interceptions to go along with 891 rushing yards and six rushing scores.
Daniels led Washington to a 12-5 finish, their best record since 1991. He led them to a thrilling Wild Card Round victory over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Washington’s first playoff win in 19 years.
Continuing the magic, the Daniels’ Commanders shocked the 15-win and top-seeded Detroit Lions in the Divisional Round. The magical run ended with a blowout loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in the NFC Championship Game, but it nonetheless appeared to be the start of something special in DC.
Unfortunately, Daniels’s sophomore season was a nightmare in every aspect. He was limited to three games because of hamstring and knee sprains as well as a dislocated elbow. And don’t mind us for already fearing that Daniels could be the next Robert Griffin III in Washington.
Like RG3, Washington showed zero concern or regard for Daniels’ well-being last season. And in hindsight, we should have realized that 2024 was a fluky year, where Washington broke the analytics with their unsustainable success on fourth-down plays.
Also, the Commanders’ roster is lousy outside of Daniels and Terry McLaurin. Their three NFC East rivals all have much deeper rosters and more cornerstone pieces. So, don’t mind us thinking that 2024 was peak Jayden Daniels.
Not like Washington’s got a rich history of developing star NFL QBs these days, too.
Become A Hall Of Famer: Will Anderson Jr.
The Houston Texans got bold at the 2023 NFL Draft. After using the No. 2 pick on Ohio State quarterback CJ Stroud, they traded up via the Arizona Cardinals to select Alabama edge rusher Will Anderson Jr. at No. 3 overall.
While Stroud has been a model of…inconsistency…Anderson Jr. already looks like someone who’ll take JJ Watt’s status as the Texans’ franchise GOAT. No, it’s not too early to say that after three seasons.
Anderson has been a game-wrecking menace, with 30 sacks, six pass breakups, and four forced fumbles over his first three seasons. Houston also reached the Divisional Round in each of Anderson’s first three seasons. No small feat for a franchise that only had four playoff wins over its first 18 years of existence.
Credit head coach DeMeco Ryans for helping unlock Anderson’s potential. The 2025 Texans’ defense was one of the best ever, and Stroud’s lousy postseason performance doesn’t take that away.
We’re still waiting to see what the deal is with Stroud. But Anderson, at this rate, looks like a lock for Canton.
Fizzle Out: Jordan Addison
Addison looked like a budding NFL star after a phenomenal 2023 rookie season. Even though the Minnesota Vikings had to use four different starting quarterbacks that year, Addison still finished with 70 receptions for 911 yards and 10 touchdowns.
If Addison could post those numbers with guys like Josh Dobbs and Nick Mullens throwing to him…just what could he do with a capable starting quarterback?
Not much, apparently.
Before the start of the 2024 season, Addison was arrested in Los Angeles for suspicion of driving under the influence. It was only the start of his off-the-field issues.
He missed two games in 2024, but the 63-875-9 stat line was still a disappointment, considering how excellent Sam Darnold was behind center for the Vikings in 2024.
Addison struggled through a forgettable 2025 season, catching 42 passes for 610 yards and three touchdowns. He was also credited with six drops.
A week after the Vikings’ 2025 campaign ended, Addison was again arrested for misdemeanor trespassing in Tampa. Another terrible look for a receiver whose production has declined in consecutive seasons.
So, we’re just left thinking maybe Addison isn’t the star that looked to be in development in 2023. The production isn’t there. The off-field issues for a player this young are awfully concerning, too.
Maybe Addison as an NFL superstar just wasn’t meant to be…
Become A Hall Of Famer: Caleb Williams
The Chicago Bears have been a quarterback graveyard for decades. But it looks like the No. 1 pick of the 2024 NFL Draft will buck the trend as he’s a bona fide star.
Williams had a superb rookie season despite coaching malpractice — hi Matt Eberflus! — and taking a league-high 68 sacks. He threw for 3,541 yards, 20 touchdowns, and only six interceptions.
Of course, the party really started after the Bears hired Ben Johnson. He helped Williams take his game to another level in 2025, throwing for 3,942 yards, 27 touchdowns, and seven picks.
Williams had six fourth-quarter comebacks in the regular season. To say nothing of that epic comeback win over the archrival Green Bay Packers in the Wild Card Round — and the NEAR-MIRACLE comeback in an overtime loss to the Rams in the Divisional Round.
Williams has displayed all-world quarterback play since coming to Windy City. He was this-close to getting them to the NFC title game in his sophomore year. And his partnership with Johnson is just getting started.
You see the jaw-dropping quarterback play, clutch genesis, and ridiculous poise. Yeah, the Bears are gonna send a QB to the Hall of Fame in the 21st century, folks! Ya better believe it.
Fizzle Out: Kayvon Thibodeaux
It’s easy to forget now, but Thibodeaux was once considered an early front-runner to go first overall in a relatively weak 2022 NFL Draft. The Jacksonville Jaguars would use the top pick on Travon Walker, with Thibodeaux eventually going fifth overall to the New York Giants.
Thibodeaux showed some flashes in his rookie year, but he looked like a future superstar with an excellent 2023 season. Thibodeaux finished with 11.5 sacks, four pass breakups, and three forced fumbles.
But it’s been downhill for the Oregon product ever since. Injuries limited him to 22 games over the 2024 and 2025 seasons. He was hardly noticeable with eight sacks in those games. And his Pro Football Focus metrics haven’t been pretty.
Thibodeaux has had four years now to put it together. Instead, he looks like a rotational player at best.
Become A Hall Of Famer: Kyle Hamilton
Hamilton was considered a top-five prospect entering the 2022 NFL Draft. But fortunately for the Baltimore Ravens, other teams didn’t value the safety position that early. So, the Notre Dame product fell right into their laps at No. 14 overall.
The fit has been perfect, as everyone expected. Hamilton has made a strong case as arguably the best defensive back in the NFL and certainly the best star safety by a country mile.
Hamilton has been lights out in coverage, pass rushing, and run defense. Through four seasons, the three-time Pro Bowler had five interceptions, 36 pass breakups, six forced fumbles, and eight sacks with only a 76.8 passer rating allowed when targeted.
All of this accomplished before his 25th birthday? Yeah, this kid is definitely in the Hall of Fame. But can he follow the footsteps of Ravens legend and Hall of Fame safety Ed Reed and eventually claim a Super Bowl championship ring?
Fizzle Out: C.J. Stroud
The year before Jayden Daniels went off, Stroud put together his own season that many viewed as the best rookie QB campaign in NFL history.
Despite missing two starts, Stroud threw for 4,108 yards, 23 touchdowns, and only five picks for a passer rating of 100.8. Stroud led Houston to the AFC South division crown and a wild-card round victory over the Cleveland Browns before bowing out to the Baltimore Ravens in the Divisional Round.
Despite playing all 17 games in 2024, however, Stroud actually finished with fewer passing yards and touchdowns at 3,727 and 20, respectively. His passer rating fell to 87.0.
Then in 2025? Stroud missed three games, had 19 touchdowns and eight picks. Then he wasted the Texans’ generational defense by self-destructing in their Divisional Round loss with four interceptions in a 28-16 loss to the Patriots.
Houston’s got a stupendous defense and a good set of receivers. Stroud, however, has regressed more and more since his lights-out rookie year. And given his disappointing playoff performances up to this point, it’s safe to question if Stroud will ever become “the guy” in Houston.
Or anywhere else…
Become A Hall Of Famer: Puka Nacua
What more can be said about Nacua that hasn’t already been said? He’s thriving off the field, too.
The Los Angeles Rams struck gold when they drafted Nacua in the fifth round — 177th overall — in 2023. See? There’s a reason why GM Les Snead gets away with trading first-round picks as they grow on trees…
In 2023, Nacua set the rookie records for receptions with 105 and receiving yards with 1,486. Despite missing six games in his sophomore year, Nacua racked up 79 receptions for 990 yards and three touchdowns.
Nacua was instrumental in Matthew Stafford claiming his first NFL MVP award in 2025. Nacua recorded a league-leading 129 receptions for 1,715 yards and 10 touchdowns to earn the first of many First-team All-Pro selections.
Through three seasons, Nacua has 313 receptions for 4,191 yards and 19 touchdowns. In the postseason, he has 44 catches for 654 yards and three touchdowns. This is Justin Jefferson and Randy Moss-like production for a receiver before his 25th birthday, folks. NFL star, no doubt.
Nacua is also in a good spot to keep on producing with Sean McVay running the offense. Honestly, three more seasons like this could be enough to get him in the Hall of Fame. Now, if Nacua could just get that Super Bowl ring while he has Stafford throwing to him…
Fizzle Out: Rashee Rice
Rice’s rookie season couldn’t have gone a whole lot better. The No. 55 pick of 2023 emerged as the Kansas City Chiefs’ top wide receiver, catching 79 passes for 938 yards and seven touchdowns.
Rice played a vital role in the Chiefs’ Super Bowl 58 run, catching 26 passes for 262 yards and a touchdown. Kansas City defeated the San Francisco 49ers in overtime to repeat as Super Bowl champions, a feat that hadn’t been accomplished since the 2003-04 New England Patriots.
Less than two months after the Chiefs’ Super Bowl 58 triumph, Rice was involved in a Dallas hit-and-run while racing his friend on a highway. He later pleaded guilty to a pair of felony charges and was sentenced to 30 days in prison. Rice was also suspended for six games in 2025.
In Week 4 of the 2024 season, Rice suffered a gruesome knee injury that required surgery. That sidelines him for the rest of the year. He performed well in the eight games he suited up for in 2025. But that might be the last we see of Prime Rashee Rice.
After the season, Rice’s ex-girlfriend accused him of viciously assaulting her during their relationship. She even posted photos showing the gruesome injuries as well as damage in her home, allegedly inflicted by Rice.
After the Super Bowl, the ex-girlfriend filed a lawsuit against Rice.
Rice clearly can’t be relied upon to have a clean act and focus on football. The Chiefs have faced plenty of criticism in the past for employing players with baggage like Tyreek Hill, Frank Clark, and Kareem Hunt. Can they really go through this again with Rice?
It just feels like Rice’s problematic off-the-field behavior is bound to destroy what should have been a blossoming tenure in Kansas City. And sadly, the young star wouldn’t be the first player to throw away his NFL career with significant legal matters.
