TRZ Ad
2025NFLPro Bowl Week

Internet Sleuths Think They’ve Identified Joe Burrow’s Mystery Girlfriend, But One Clue Is Raising Serious Question Marks [PHOTOS]

1

This article was originally published on Total Pro Sports.

Joe Burrow and his mystery girlfriend
Joe Burrow and his mystery girlfriend (Photo via Instagram & Imagn Images)

Social media never takes a day off, and Joe Burrow has given them something to do with just one post.

Burrow has been linked to Olivia Ponton for over a year now, even as both of them continue to be pretty private about it. The Bengals star quarterback and Ponton were pictured in New York City during the first weekend of summer in 2025.

Now, fans are wondering if she is out of the picture altogether. It all stemmed from Burrow posting a picture on his Instagram story of a woman he was seated across from. The picture appeared to be of Kendall Jenner, who was just on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon.

Several fans were sure of it:

“She gave us the playbook, and we didn’t even know it,” one person wrote.

“Is that not Kendall Jenner?” a second person added.

“Has to be Kendal Jenner,” a third person inserted.

“Is that Kendall Jenner?” One final person asked about Joe Burrow’s picture.

Social Media Might Be Wrong About Joe Burrow’s Mysterious Woman

Joe Burrow in uniform
Joe Burrow (Sam Greene/The Enquirer-USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images)

There are rumblings that Kendall Jenner is dating Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow. It first started with Jenner after she donned a Bengals-inspired outfit during her appearance on “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon” on Thursday.

The links between Jenner and Burrow made headlines after an Instagram story showed her on what appeared to be a dinner date with him.

It turns out that everybody was wrong. One person pointed out the phone on the table that was different from the one she had with Fallon. “Definitely not Kendall as its a different phone that was on Jimmy Fallon,” the X user wrote.

TMZ would later get down to the bottom of things. They reported that two doctored pictures surfaced online around the same time. One of them was of Joe Burrow posting Kendall and Jenner posting him. It turns out the Kendall picture is at least five years old.

Their sources told them that neither Instagram story was real.

Teams