tixwork-420×60

“We Need Someone New” – NFL Fans Are Begging ‘Sunday Night Football’ To Replace Carrie Underwood

This article was originally published on Total Pro Sports.

Cris Collinsworth sitting with Carrie Underwood and Mike Tirico
Cris Collinsworth, recording artist Carrie Underwood and NBC Sunday Night Football play-by-play announcer Mike Tirico (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

Carrie Underwood has become a Sunday Night Football staple after performing the anthem for well over a decade. But it appears some fans have grown weary.

The 43-year-old country star, who rose to fame on American Idol, started in 2013 when she replaced Faith Hill. 

NBC announced a new 2026 open in August. NBC Insider quotes her calling it “one of my most favorite opens yet!”

One fan still wants a different voice next season. They posted during Sunday night’s Bengals-Steelers game, drawing close to 130,000 views.

“we all agree that next season we need a new artist singing the SNF anthem right???” the fan wrote.

“God I’ve been saying this forever, please we need someone new. It’s been 14 years, Carrie is washed, she has had her time on SNF,” someone agreed.

“Faith Hill sang it for 6 seasons. Carrie has sung for 14. Time for somebody new. I want Kelly Clarkson. She can sing anything and is a big football fan,” said another.

Someone else chimed in, saying it’s “way overdue,”

“Speak for yourself. I have no problem with Carrie,” another fan said, pushing back.

NBC Debuted A Rock-Leaning Anthem Remake During The September Season Premiere

Carrie Underwood singing on stage.
Carrie Underwood (Andrew Nelles / The Tennessean-USA TODAY NETWORK)

The new open premiered on September 13 during the Dallas Cowboys-New York Giants game. NBC Insider says it reworks the Joan Jett song I Hate Myself for Loving You into Waiting All Day for Sunday Night.

Given that Underwood replaced Faith Hill, a change would not be unprecedented.

Some fans voiced similar frustration earlier, including calls to get Underwood fired ahead of the 2026 season. 

Teams